I've never been all that drawn to Joyce Carol Oates, but the vagaries and vicissitudes of life--and the shortcomings of a textbook--have forced me into reading some of her work that I would have happily left untouched. Still, even in the least pleasant reading there is typically something to learn. If you want delve into Oates' short fiction, you could do worse than with High Lonesome.
"The Lady with the Pet Dog," although a tale of adultery justified, holds some interest for the Christian reader. Far from the many tales of adultery punished, including films like Unfaithful or Fatal Attraction, Oates relates the story of a wife who, for apparently no real reason, opts to engage in an illicit tryst and then, after breaking it off once, to resume it. In the story's end, Anna, the only named character among the key three, feels, "joyfully . . . a miraculous calm." She "discovers" or rationalizes to herself that this man, despite her marriage to another man and her lover's marriage to another woman, "was her husband truly--they were truly married, here in this room--they had been married haphazardly and accidentally for a long time."
Anna, like the protagonist of Kate Chopin's The Awakening, has no significant complaint about her marriage. She cannot point to abuse or lack of support or infidelity on the part of her husband. Granted, the husband is not painted by Oates in a particularly flattering manner, but the reader is left to wonder whether his greatest fault is his lack sensitivity or his declining physical appearance. The husband's insensitivity is evidenced while they're making love: "her husband was impatient. He was apart from her, working on her, operating on her; and then, stricken, he whispered, 'Did I hurt you?'" While nobody wants this guy as their Valentine, this sort of callousness is hardly a hanging offense. Couple that fact with Anna's reaction during the same act. "He made love to her and she was back in the auditorium again" seeing her lover. Might the fault for her husband's detachment lie in both of their hearts and minds?
The glorious faux "marriage" that Anna celebrates as the story closes is, of course, no marriage at all. It is a series of liaisons, experienced furtively in a different hotel room each week. This relationship, experienced in darkness, evokes the teachings in 1 John 1:5-10. This is not marriage. The shame that Anna mentions several times during the story should be a real shame, but she manages, at the story's conclusion, to smooth it over, to decide that her shame should not be shame at all, but this is something that she can do only by playing semantic games, deciding that her husband is no real husband at all and that her affair is somehow a real marriage, playing the sort of games that Paul decries in Romans 1:25.
Of course, Oates would not have seen things in this light. She seems to admire the development Anna achieves by the story's close. However, her re-identification of evil as good is no more convincing or authoritative than is Anna's.
Showing posts with label short stories. Show all posts
Showing posts with label short stories. Show all posts
Monday, March 10, 2008
Wednesday, March 5, 2008
Raymond Carver--Cathedral
Raymond Carver's short story, "Cathedral," is, like so many of this author's stories, a peculiar piece of work. Populated by mostly unsympathetic characters living drab lives, Carver's work stands a long distance from the classic narrative structures of O. Henry and Guy Du Maupassant.
In this story, an unnamed husband and wife play host to the blind former employer of the wife. The husband and narrator of the story does not want the blind man, Robert to come over. In fact, he doesn't seem to want anybody to come over. This character leads a hopelessly detached life. When he protests that he doesn't have any blind friends, his wife replies by noting "You don't have any friends. Period."
Although married, he and his wife sleep in separate rooms. They rarely go to bed at the same time. Instead, he sits up watching meaningless TV late into the night. Clearly the couple don't have much meaningful communication of any sort. The husband dislikes his job. He's just an alienated being bobbing along through life, moving toward death because there's nothing else to do.
Robert, we're told, has just lost his wife, Beulah. What an intriguing name that is, Beulah. It derives from a Hebrew word meaning married. Is that significant? I think so. In fact, I think the entire existence of Beulah is important. Carver could have easily portrayed Robert simply as the wife's former employer without the baggage of a recently deceased wife, but he compounds the significance by describing Beulah as the reader who came to work for Robert after the wife gave up the job. It doesn't take too much imagination to wonder if the wife didn't see herself in Beulah's shoes. She could have married Robert, but instead she married this guy who, although sighted, is as blind as can be.
Why is it, do you suppose, that Robert and Beulah have names while the husband and wife, clearly the closer characters to the narrator, do not have names? I would suggest that these names indicate the greater reality of these characters. Although blind and dead, respectively, Robert and Beulah have experienced what the husband and wife have never experienced, connecting in a way they have never connected.
The name "Beulah" also evokes images of the Promised Land or the land of peace in John Bunyan's Pilgrim's Progress. This suggests to me that there's more to this idea of connection than just friendship. Raymond Carver is not known as a religious writer, but here he seems to be describing a character with a God-shaped hole, a hole that he cannot fill with the alcohol he continues to drink throughout the story, the marijuana that he persuades Robert to share, his pointless job, his marriage-in-name-only, or his late-night television marathons.
What does eventually fill the husband's void or at least suggest the potential of filling is a moment of communion when he and Robert together hold a pen and draw an image of a cathedral. One can imagine this bit of collaborative art as an act of worship, or at least an act of potential worship. Is that what Carver intended? I don't think so, but often artists say more than they ever intend to say when they put pen to paper.
"Cathedral" is the title story in a fine collection of Carver's work.
In this story, an unnamed husband and wife play host to the blind former employer of the wife. The husband and narrator of the story does not want the blind man, Robert to come over. In fact, he doesn't seem to want anybody to come over. This character leads a hopelessly detached life. When he protests that he doesn't have any blind friends, his wife replies by noting "You don't have any friends. Period."
Although married, he and his wife sleep in separate rooms. They rarely go to bed at the same time. Instead, he sits up watching meaningless TV late into the night. Clearly the couple don't have much meaningful communication of any sort. The husband dislikes his job. He's just an alienated being bobbing along through life, moving toward death because there's nothing else to do.
Robert, we're told, has just lost his wife, Beulah. What an intriguing name that is, Beulah. It derives from a Hebrew word meaning married. Is that significant? I think so. In fact, I think the entire existence of Beulah is important. Carver could have easily portrayed Robert simply as the wife's former employer without the baggage of a recently deceased wife, but he compounds the significance by describing Beulah as the reader who came to work for Robert after the wife gave up the job. It doesn't take too much imagination to wonder if the wife didn't see herself in Beulah's shoes. She could have married Robert, but instead she married this guy who, although sighted, is as blind as can be.
Why is it, do you suppose, that Robert and Beulah have names while the husband and wife, clearly the closer characters to the narrator, do not have names? I would suggest that these names indicate the greater reality of these characters. Although blind and dead, respectively, Robert and Beulah have experienced what the husband and wife have never experienced, connecting in a way they have never connected.
The name "Beulah" also evokes images of the Promised Land or the land of peace in John Bunyan's Pilgrim's Progress. This suggests to me that there's more to this idea of connection than just friendship. Raymond Carver is not known as a religious writer, but here he seems to be describing a character with a God-shaped hole, a hole that he cannot fill with the alcohol he continues to drink throughout the story, the marijuana that he persuades Robert to share, his pointless job, his marriage-in-name-only, or his late-night television marathons.
What does eventually fill the husband's void or at least suggest the potential of filling is a moment of communion when he and Robert together hold a pen and draw an image of a cathedral. One can imagine this bit of collaborative art as an act of worship, or at least an act of potential worship. Is that what Carver intended? I don't think so, but often artists say more than they ever intend to say when they put pen to paper.
"Cathedral" is the title story in a fine collection of Carver's work.
Saturday, February 16, 2008
Shusaku Endo—The Final Martyrs
Another new author from Eyes to See, is Shusaku Endo, whose story “The Final Martyrs” takes the reader into an unfamiliar world, that of crypto-Christians during the politically turbulent times of nineteenth-century Japan. In reading this story, which explores, not surprisingly, the experience of persecution and martyrdom, my mind returned to “Sea and Sunset,” a story of thirteenth-century Japan by Yukio Mishima. Mishima, not an author particularly inclined toward Christianity, relates the utter otherness of a young European man brought as a slave to Japan in the aftermath of the abortive Children’s Crusade.
While Endo’s story stands as a fairly unremarkable study of the psychology of persecution, I find it intriguing for its location in an incredibly hostile, incredibly foreign locale. Both Endo’s and Mishima’s stories locate Christianity in a profoundly isolated place. The cavalry will not be riding in to save the day in either story. Comfort and hope will not be arriving from any external source. This leaves the would-be martyr in a vulnerable position, while affording him a purity of action. No one can ascribe political or social motivations to the steadfastness of these persecuted Christians. Perhaps most importantly, their potential for self-delusion, while not eliminated, is diminished.
While Endo’s story stands as a fairly unremarkable study of the psychology of persecution, I find it intriguing for its location in an incredibly hostile, incredibly foreign locale. Both Endo’s and Mishima’s stories locate Christianity in a profoundly isolated place. The cavalry will not be riding in to save the day in either story. Comfort and hope will not be arriving from any external source. This leaves the would-be martyr in a vulnerable position, while affording him a purity of action. No one can ascribe political or social motivations to the steadfastness of these persecuted Christians. Perhaps most importantly, their potential for self-delusion, while not eliminated, is diminished.
Andre Dubus—A Father’s Story
Before picking up Eyes to See, I had never heard of Andre Dubus, a Louisiana product and yet another in the outflow of the Iowa Writer’s Workshop. “A Father’s Story” did not suffice to make me rush out to buy all of Dubus’ books, but it is a story worth reading. The narrator of the story is Luke Ripley, a divorced Catholic father, struggling to balance the demands of his faith with the calls of his flesh.
After a very long lead-in—roughly half the story’s length—Dubus finally arrives at the central concern of this narrative. Luke’s daughter, now a young woman, during the course of a visit, comes home late one night having struck a pedestrian with her car after a bit of drinking with friends. The conflicting calls of justice, truth, fatherly protection, and fear play out over the remaining pages of the story. It’s not brilliant stuff, but the last page or so, in which Luke relates a conversation with God regarding this event, is worth the price of admission, worth the time invested in the story’s thirty pages.
Rather than analyzing this discourse myself, I’d rather leave it to you with a couple of questions. Does Dubus, through Ripley, rationalize his choices in the wake of the accident? In other words, is the voice that he ascribes to God really a God-worthy voice or is it more a self-justifying version of his own voice? I’ve always taken the Socratic dialogues of Plato with a bit of skepticism. After all, it is rather easy to win an argument when you’re responsible for both sides of it.
How often do we, as thoughtful believers, generate a pseudo-God voice in order to justify the actions that we intended to take all along? Is that what Luke Ripley is doing here? I don’t think that is the intention with which Dubus presents him, which may explain that apparently overlong exposition in the story’s first half.
After a very long lead-in—roughly half the story’s length—Dubus finally arrives at the central concern of this narrative. Luke’s daughter, now a young woman, during the course of a visit, comes home late one night having struck a pedestrian with her car after a bit of drinking with friends. The conflicting calls of justice, truth, fatherly protection, and fear play out over the remaining pages of the story. It’s not brilliant stuff, but the last page or so, in which Luke relates a conversation with God regarding this event, is worth the price of admission, worth the time invested in the story’s thirty pages.
Rather than analyzing this discourse myself, I’d rather leave it to you with a couple of questions. Does Dubus, through Ripley, rationalize his choices in the wake of the accident? In other words, is the voice that he ascribes to God really a God-worthy voice or is it more a self-justifying version of his own voice? I’ve always taken the Socratic dialogues of Plato with a bit of skepticism. After all, it is rather easy to win an argument when you’re responsible for both sides of it.
How often do we, as thoughtful believers, generate a pseudo-God voice in order to justify the actions that we intended to take all along? Is that what Luke Ripley is doing here? I don’t think that is the intention with which Dubus presents him, which may explain that apparently overlong exposition in the story’s first half.
Friday, February 8, 2008
Fyodor Dostoevsky—“An Honest Thief”
The second story in Eyes to See is this story by Dostoevsky, an author with the same level of religious intensity as that possessed by Chesterton, but a profoundly greater narrative facility. “An Honest Thief” is a simple story but at the same time a vexing one.
The basic plot is simple. Astafy, a lodger in the home of a reluctant landlord tells a second-hand tale about an honest thief. This thief, Emelyan, also a lodger of sorts, had stolen riding breaches from Astafy, his benefactor. Emelyan denies the crime vehemently, yet his actions proclaim his guilt more clearly than would a confession. Eventually, apparently sick with his sense of guilt—or perhaps just sick—Emelyan lies on his deathbed and confesses the theft of the breeches to a sympathetic Astafy.
Complicating this story, however, is the narratological structure. Why must Dostoevsky employ the framing story with Astafy speaking to the narrator? Granted, the narrator has just been deprived of an overcoat by a wandering thief, but might the story not be told without this device?
In order to read Dostoevsky in this case, we should consider the character of the narrator for a moment. This is a significantly isolated man, holed up in his home office, rarely speaking with anyone. He confesses to having no meaningful conversation with his housekeeper for six years. He describes himself, upon first meeting Astafy as follows: “I lead as a rule a very lonely hermit’s existence. I have scarcely any friends; I hardly ever go anywhere. As I had spent ten years never coming out of my shell, I had, of course, grown used to solitude.”
The rationale for Astafy telling his story in response to the theft of the overcoat is obvious, but why did Dostoevsky need this narrative frame? I would suggest that this story is not about an honest thief. Emelyan is not the true focus of the story. Instead, the narrator is the character most changed in the course of these pages. Let me explain.
At the outset, as noted, our narrator is a hermit. Upon admitting Astafy to his life, he breaks with his old habits and makes a connection, however tentative, with another human being. This represents a first step to full humanity, yet it’s not enough. How remarkable is it for a man to love his friends? That’s nothing remarkable at all. But loving an enemy is significant. (I seem to have read this sort of thing before.)
The narrator’s initial response to the theft of his overcoat is surprisingly restrained. In fact, it is Astafy who seems the more concerned about the crime. It is he, despite his advanced age, who runs after the thief. It is he who continues to bring up the topic and express anger. Yet then it is Astafy who tells the story of his experience with Emelyan. In the course of those pages, Astafy fully humanizes the weaker man, Emelyan, so that in the end, while the reader and the narrator do not condone the thief’s conduct, we see that conduct as the action of a frail vessel, fatally marked by sin.
A moment ago, I suggested that the narrator is a changed figure by the end of the story, but is there evidence for such a claim? The fact of his narration is, I would argue, such evidence. I would compare this to the biblical book of Philemon. Paul sends a runaway slave, Onesimus, back to his owner, Philemon, along with a letter. In the letter, Paul implores Philemon to treat Onesimus as brother in Christ. What evidence do we have that Philemon heeded Paul’s advice? I believe that the survival of the letter suggests that course. Similarly, we should not expect the narrator to tell such a tale if he found it to be nonsense.
The basic plot is simple. Astafy, a lodger in the home of a reluctant landlord tells a second-hand tale about an honest thief. This thief, Emelyan, also a lodger of sorts, had stolen riding breaches from Astafy, his benefactor. Emelyan denies the crime vehemently, yet his actions proclaim his guilt more clearly than would a confession. Eventually, apparently sick with his sense of guilt—or perhaps just sick—Emelyan lies on his deathbed and confesses the theft of the breeches to a sympathetic Astafy.
Complicating this story, however, is the narratological structure. Why must Dostoevsky employ the framing story with Astafy speaking to the narrator? Granted, the narrator has just been deprived of an overcoat by a wandering thief, but might the story not be told without this device?
In order to read Dostoevsky in this case, we should consider the character of the narrator for a moment. This is a significantly isolated man, holed up in his home office, rarely speaking with anyone. He confesses to having no meaningful conversation with his housekeeper for six years. He describes himself, upon first meeting Astafy as follows: “I lead as a rule a very lonely hermit’s existence. I have scarcely any friends; I hardly ever go anywhere. As I had spent ten years never coming out of my shell, I had, of course, grown used to solitude.”
The rationale for Astafy telling his story in response to the theft of the overcoat is obvious, but why did Dostoevsky need this narrative frame? I would suggest that this story is not about an honest thief. Emelyan is not the true focus of the story. Instead, the narrator is the character most changed in the course of these pages. Let me explain.
At the outset, as noted, our narrator is a hermit. Upon admitting Astafy to his life, he breaks with his old habits and makes a connection, however tentative, with another human being. This represents a first step to full humanity, yet it’s not enough. How remarkable is it for a man to love his friends? That’s nothing remarkable at all. But loving an enemy is significant. (I seem to have read this sort of thing before.)
The narrator’s initial response to the theft of his overcoat is surprisingly restrained. In fact, it is Astafy who seems the more concerned about the crime. It is he, despite his advanced age, who runs after the thief. It is he who continues to bring up the topic and express anger. Yet then it is Astafy who tells the story of his experience with Emelyan. In the course of those pages, Astafy fully humanizes the weaker man, Emelyan, so that in the end, while the reader and the narrator do not condone the thief’s conduct, we see that conduct as the action of a frail vessel, fatally marked by sin.
A moment ago, I suggested that the narrator is a changed figure by the end of the story, but is there evidence for such a claim? The fact of his narration is, I would argue, such evidence. I would compare this to the biblical book of Philemon. Paul sends a runaway slave, Onesimus, back to his owner, Philemon, along with a letter. In the letter, Paul implores Philemon to treat Onesimus as brother in Christ. What evidence do we have that Philemon heeded Paul’s advice? I believe that the survival of the letter suggests that course. Similarly, we should not expect the narrator to tell such a tale if he found it to be nonsense.
G.K. Chesterton—The Blue Cross
Chesterton’s Father Brown, while no Sherlock Holmes, stands as one of the significant figures in detective fiction. Frankly, I’d argue that no detective fiction is “great literature,” whatever that means, but it is enjoyed by millions of people. I suppose enjoyment constitutes greatness in one sense.
Without doing a bit more research, I can’t say whether “The Blue Cross” is the first of Chesterton’s invocations of the detective-priest. Regardless, this story does not have the typical structure of a detective tale.
In the midst of this ungreat literature, I find several points of interest for the Christian reader:
First, Brown stands in a noble crossroads for the educated believer, straddling the way of faith and of reason. Is intellect is powerful, yet it does not preclude his belief. His belief is profound, yet it does not compromise his intellect. I believe that the Christian is called to stand at just such a place.
Second, the great secular detective, Valentin, on whom ninety percent of this story dwells, exists solely in the realm of intellect and reason. While Valentin’s powers are significant and lead him toward the consummation of the case, he finds himself beaten to the case’s solution by the more rounded Brown.
Finally, the revelation of Brown toward the end of the story performs a powerful reversal. All through the story, the smaller priest has been portrayed as a hapless lamb, about to be sheared by the wily Flambeau, yet in the end, it is he who does the shearing. Father Brown here stands as a sort of Christ figure, a man who in the limited vision of the world seems mildly annoying and largely worthless, yet, when seen fully, in the largest context, is found to be incredibly more powerful and competent than initially suspected.
So, great literature or not, Chesterton’s story offers something of worth to the willing reader.
Without doing a bit more research, I can’t say whether “The Blue Cross” is the first of Chesterton’s invocations of the detective-priest. Regardless, this story does not have the typical structure of a detective tale.
In the midst of this ungreat literature, I find several points of interest for the Christian reader:
First, Brown stands in a noble crossroads for the educated believer, straddling the way of faith and of reason. Is intellect is powerful, yet it does not preclude his belief. His belief is profound, yet it does not compromise his intellect. I believe that the Christian is called to stand at just such a place.
Second, the great secular detective, Valentin, on whom ninety percent of this story dwells, exists solely in the realm of intellect and reason. While Valentin’s powers are significant and lead him toward the consummation of the case, he finds himself beaten to the case’s solution by the more rounded Brown.
Finally, the revelation of Brown toward the end of the story performs a powerful reversal. All through the story, the smaller priest has been portrayed as a hapless lamb, about to be sheared by the wily Flambeau, yet in the end, it is he who does the shearing. Father Brown here stands as a sort of Christ figure, a man who in the limited vision of the world seems mildly annoying and largely worthless, yet, when seen fully, in the largest context, is found to be incredibly more powerful and competent than initially suspected.
So, great literature or not, Chesterton’s story offers something of worth to the willing reader.
Eyes to See
I recently purchased a new collection of short stories, Eyes to See, edited by Bret Lott (Thomas Nelson: Nashville, 2008). My first reaction upon scanning over the table of contents was to be disappointed. I’m not sure what I was expecting, but once I noticed a couple of familiar titles—“A Good Man is Hard to Find” prominent among them—I felt as if I had just bought the same thing in a different package. However, having dropped a good chunk of money on the volume, I needed to at least pretend to read it. Once I got inside the front cover, I continued through story after story, only skipping over Flannery O’Connor. Therefore, it seems reasonable to give some of these stories a bit of attention in these postings. By this point, I can recommend the investment in the book.
Tuesday, February 5, 2008
The Minister’s Black Veil—Nathaniel Hawthorne
Few stories in American literature have been given the scrutiny of this one by Hawthorne. Researchers will find very little trouble in gathering dozens upon dozens of interpretations upon this story. What is perhaps most intriguing is the lengths that various critics will go to in order to strip this story of its most obvious interpretation.
First, let’s briefly summarize the story. The tale opens on a Sunday with morning services about to begin. All seems normal until Rev. Hooper exits the rectory to preach the service, inexplicably wearing a double fold of black crepe over the upper half of his face. The appearance of the minister greatly disturbs his parishioners. After a funeral and a wedding that day, Rev. Hooper meets with his fiancĂ©e, Elizabeth. When he refuses to set the veil aside for her, she breaks off the engagement although remaining quite devoted to him.
Years pass by as Hooper maintains the black veil. He becomes a more effective preacher during these years although remaining an enigma to his flock. Finally, as he lies on his deathbed, another minister, Rev. Clark, urges him to finally remove the veil. Hooper refuses, aided by Elizabeth, and dies covered by the black cloth.
In order to understand this story, one must begin and end the interpretation—or at least its heart—with the veil. Why does Hooper wear the veil? Is he hiding something or hiding from something? Alternately, is the veil a tool for concealment or for signification. The most obvious interpretation, and the one that most of the congregation apparently assume to be true, is that Hooper has committed some horrible sin and wears the veil in order to hide his face in shame. Edgar Allan Poe theorized that Hooper had committed a sexual sin with the young woman whose funeral he performs that first day. While such is a possibility, it, I believe, takes the story to a too-literal level. On the other hand, the veil might be a tool to shield Hooper’s eyes from other people.
Looking at the alternate scheme of understanding the veil, we might wonder if Hooper wears to veil to cover something up or to reveal something. Perhaps the veil indicates his awareness of sin. If so, then we might profitably ask whether the sin signified is his own or someone else’s?
Some readers have picked up on a Biblical usage of veils. In II Corinthians 3:13, Paul contrasts the boldness of the believer with Moses, who veiled himself in Exodus 34 after meeting with God on Sinai. As Moses descended from his meetings with God, the glory would gradually fade away from his face. Moses delivered God’s message to the people with an uncovered, radiant face, and then covered his face until the next meeting. As tantalizing as this reference is, one might find it difficult to connect Hooper’s view of the veil with this Mosaic veiling. It seems clear in Hawthorne’s story that the key to the veil is sin. The key to the veil in the Moses story is the glory and radiance of God. These seem to be two wholly different things.
In fact, though, these two things are not nearly as separate as they might appear at first blush. Moses veiled his face in order to hide the contrast between his radiant, God-drenched face and a merely human face. The key to understanding sin in its Biblical form is to see it as separation from God, a deviation from holiness.
Hooper’s veil, whatever its origin, has the effect of emphasizing man’s lack of holiness and separation from God. This is the sort of emphasis that runs through all of Paul’s writings. In fact, this is the realization that emerges in Paul’s Damascus Road experience. Paul, convinced of his righteousness, travels toward Damascus in order to expose the failings of others. Upon encountering Christ on the road, Paul’s eyes are blinded—a sort of veiling—yet his self-perception is opened. He sees himself as a sinful man, hopeless but for the salvation offered through Christ Jesus. We only know these things, of course, because Paul has related them, either directly or by way of Luke. Recall that his fellow travelers could not hear distinct words during the event.
Does Hooper experience his own Damascus Road event? Hawthorne, by his ambiguity, ensures that readers will not know without assistance from Hooper, and the minister is not willing to testify of whatever experience has placed the veil on his face.
What places the veil on Hooper’s face? That is a cause that we will never know. Perhaps Hawthorne intends this ambiguity to allow the reader to interpret it through his own lens. I am reminded here of the many reactions I have witnessed to Paul’s II Corinthians 12 account of his thorn in the flesh. Since Paul leaves the thorn extremely ambiguous, many readers have interpreted it according to their own weaknesses.
In the end, Hawthorne’s story stands as a latter-day account of the Puritan view of man’s sinfulness and need for God. Any interpretation that leaves this aspect out of “The Minister’s Black Veil” is hiding something—or perhaps hiding from something.
First, let’s briefly summarize the story. The tale opens on a Sunday with morning services about to begin. All seems normal until Rev. Hooper exits the rectory to preach the service, inexplicably wearing a double fold of black crepe over the upper half of his face. The appearance of the minister greatly disturbs his parishioners. After a funeral and a wedding that day, Rev. Hooper meets with his fiancĂ©e, Elizabeth. When he refuses to set the veil aside for her, she breaks off the engagement although remaining quite devoted to him.
Years pass by as Hooper maintains the black veil. He becomes a more effective preacher during these years although remaining an enigma to his flock. Finally, as he lies on his deathbed, another minister, Rev. Clark, urges him to finally remove the veil. Hooper refuses, aided by Elizabeth, and dies covered by the black cloth.
In order to understand this story, one must begin and end the interpretation—or at least its heart—with the veil. Why does Hooper wear the veil? Is he hiding something or hiding from something? Alternately, is the veil a tool for concealment or for signification. The most obvious interpretation, and the one that most of the congregation apparently assume to be true, is that Hooper has committed some horrible sin and wears the veil in order to hide his face in shame. Edgar Allan Poe theorized that Hooper had committed a sexual sin with the young woman whose funeral he performs that first day. While such is a possibility, it, I believe, takes the story to a too-literal level. On the other hand, the veil might be a tool to shield Hooper’s eyes from other people.
Looking at the alternate scheme of understanding the veil, we might wonder if Hooper wears to veil to cover something up or to reveal something. Perhaps the veil indicates his awareness of sin. If so, then we might profitably ask whether the sin signified is his own or someone else’s?
Some readers have picked up on a Biblical usage of veils. In II Corinthians 3:13, Paul contrasts the boldness of the believer with Moses, who veiled himself in Exodus 34 after meeting with God on Sinai. As Moses descended from his meetings with God, the glory would gradually fade away from his face. Moses delivered God’s message to the people with an uncovered, radiant face, and then covered his face until the next meeting. As tantalizing as this reference is, one might find it difficult to connect Hooper’s view of the veil with this Mosaic veiling. It seems clear in Hawthorne’s story that the key to the veil is sin. The key to the veil in the Moses story is the glory and radiance of God. These seem to be two wholly different things.
In fact, though, these two things are not nearly as separate as they might appear at first blush. Moses veiled his face in order to hide the contrast between his radiant, God-drenched face and a merely human face. The key to understanding sin in its Biblical form is to see it as separation from God, a deviation from holiness.
Hooper’s veil, whatever its origin, has the effect of emphasizing man’s lack of holiness and separation from God. This is the sort of emphasis that runs through all of Paul’s writings. In fact, this is the realization that emerges in Paul’s Damascus Road experience. Paul, convinced of his righteousness, travels toward Damascus in order to expose the failings of others. Upon encountering Christ on the road, Paul’s eyes are blinded—a sort of veiling—yet his self-perception is opened. He sees himself as a sinful man, hopeless but for the salvation offered through Christ Jesus. We only know these things, of course, because Paul has related them, either directly or by way of Luke. Recall that his fellow travelers could not hear distinct words during the event.
Does Hooper experience his own Damascus Road event? Hawthorne, by his ambiguity, ensures that readers will not know without assistance from Hooper, and the minister is not willing to testify of whatever experience has placed the veil on his face.
What places the veil on Hooper’s face? That is a cause that we will never know. Perhaps Hawthorne intends this ambiguity to allow the reader to interpret it through his own lens. I am reminded here of the many reactions I have witnessed to Paul’s II Corinthians 12 account of his thorn in the flesh. Since Paul leaves the thorn extremely ambiguous, many readers have interpreted it according to their own weaknesses.
In the end, Hawthorne’s story stands as a latter-day account of the Puritan view of man’s sinfulness and need for God. Any interpretation that leaves this aspect out of “The Minister’s Black Veil” is hiding something—or perhaps hiding from something.
Labels:
fiction,
Nathaniel Hawthorne,
short stories,
transcendentalism
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
